What Recessions? It's a Wonderful Life
By Elliott Wave International
Fund managers see no risk of a U.S. recession. Have they over-indulged on the eggnog?
"I don't have your money. It's in Tom's house...and Fred's house." This is a quote from George Bailey, the fictional bank manager in the 1946 classic movie, It's a Wonderful Life. George was replying to customers of the bank who were demanding their money back. Unfortunately, the deposits had been invested, and the bank did not have enough money to pay everyone out. As I have said to my 14-year-old daughter every year over the past decade when we settle down to watch this feel-good Christmas movie, it's probably the simplest, and therefore best, lesson about understanding the complexities of the fixed-fractional banking system. (As you can imagine, this just exacerbates the fact that, in her now-teenage eyes, I am boring, embarrassing dad.)
George Bailey did not expect all his customers to demand their money back at once. It may be a fictional story, but it accurately reflects the complacent psychology of financial institutions as an economic cycle tops out. The latest example of such complacency comes from the most recent Bank of America Merrill Lynch Fund Manager Survey. Expectations that global growth will improve in the next year jumped to a net 29% of respondents in December, the biggest two-month gain on record, and a big turnaround from the middle of the year when there was intense fear of a global recession. The survey shows that fund managers now see the least risk of a recession since the middle of 2009. That was, of course, when the U.S. was already in recession, despite central banks' machinations to inject liquidity into the financial system. The Fed has again begun pumping billions of dollars into the system since September, but the difference is that the U.S. has not experienced a recession as it did in 2008-2009. Are people just blindly accepting that the Fed will be able to keep the stock market propped up? Perhaps.
Indeed, some investors believe that because the yield curve has turned positive again, then all is well and there's no need to worry. On the contrary, the chart below shows that when the yield curve inverts and then turns positive, it is precisely the time to worry that a recession may be dead ahead.
It's a Wonderful Life ends with George Bailey realizing that there are much more important things in life than business. By this time next year, currently cock-a-hoop (adj.: boastfully, if not defiantly, elated) investors might be feeling the same way.
It's a commonly held misconception that a positive yield curve swing is a good sign for the economy, but the evidence proves otherwise. Want to see EWI's President, Bob Prechter, tackle and disprove other commonly held beliefs that could hinder your investing? Good!
Get instant, free access to Prechter's speech to the International Federation of Technical Analysts. It shows you “What Really Moves the Markets.” Watch Now
